Square Tube Bender Comparison Guide | Side-by-Side Review

If you’re a carport or metal framing manufacturer looking to start or expand production, choosing the right square tube bender is one of the most important decisions you can make. Depending on the products you specialize in, one hydraulic tube bender or electric square tubing bender might work better for you than another, but comparing your options can be difficult if you don’t already have a specific model in mind. That’s why we’ve created this comprehensive square tube bender comparison, reviewing six top machines so you can choose the best fit for your business.

For this guide, we’ve selected benders that are all similar in size but vary in price and production capabilities. The comparison includes our own Versabend, the Huth 2650/2660, the E-Z Bend 90, the Baileigh RDB-150, the JD Squared Model 32, and the Ercolina TB60 Top Bender.

In each case, we’re looking at new models sold directly by their manufacturers (no used or third-party listings). Every machine supports square or rectangular tube bending, and we’ve compared them according to motor/power, capacity, bending type, price, financing, country of manufacture, and shipping.

Category	Versabend (Cold Spring Enterprises Inc.)	Huth 2650 / 2660	E-Z Bend 90	Baileigh RDB-150 (Baileigh Ind.)	JD Squared Model 32 (JD2 Inc.)	Ercolina TB60 Top Bender (CML Int.)
Motor / Power	5 HP electric motor @ 1725 RPM; 220 V single-phase (22 A) (3-phase power optional)	Hydraulic system, ~58,000 lb bending force, 7.5 HP motor, knee control, auto depth-of-bend (varies by model)	Manual/lever operation; no motor (compact bench/field unit)	~2 HP hydraulic pump; 110V single-phase (standard wall outlet)	No built-in motor (manual or add-on hydraulic). Typically paired with an external pump (e.g. 110V electric ~1.5 HP or air-hydraulic) for powered operation	Servo-electric drive (no hydraulics). 3-phase power required – 480 V standard (220 V 3-phase optional). High-torque motor for CNC precision (HP not listed)
Compatible Tube Sizes	Bends 2″, 2¼″, 2½″ square tube and 2″×3″ rectangular tube (12–14 gauge) with a single die. Achieves large-radius bows in just 3 bends	Square, rectangle, and round tube bending (capacity varies by tooling). Configurations available for carports, greenhouses, picnic tables, etc.	Limited capacity; included dies for small-diameter tube; designed for 90° bends, not large-radius bows	Bends up to 2″ square steel tubing (~1/8″ wall). Also up to 2½″ round tube (.120″ wall) or 2″ Sch.40 pipe. 8″ CLR max bend radius	Bends up to 2″ square tubing (mild steel; ~0.120″ wall). Hydraulic drive required for larger sizes (over 1½″ square)	Bends up to 2″ square tube (mild steel) using rotary draw. Also up to 2½″ round tube or 2″ Sch.40 pipe
Bending Type	Hydraulic (electric pump-driven cylinder)	Hydraulic rotary draw with square/rectangular tube tooling options	Manual 90° tubing bender	Hydraulic (twin-cylinder rotary draw)	Hydraulic (manual or powered ram on rotary draw frame)	Electric (CNC rotary draw, all-electric)
Price (USD)	$19,500 (base price)	Pricing varies; typically quoted by dealer based on tooling and setup needs	Varies; generally lower-cost manual unit	~ $7,500 (base machine); tooling (dies) extra	~ $2,000–$5,000 (estimated setup). Base frame $475 + hydraulic kit $945 + pump & dies cost (modular pricing)	~ $10k–$25k (varies by configuration) Example: basic 2″ capacity model ~$10,200; fully featured TB60 ~$22–25k
Financing	Yes – flexible plans via partner	Dealer-dependent; some offer financing/leasing	Not commonly offered; may be available through dealer	Yes – financing available (in-house program)	No direct financing (third-party financing or credit card used if needed)	Varies – sold via distributors (financing/leasing often offered through dealers)
Made In / Shipping	USA – Manufactured in South Carolina. ~1,000 lb crated; ships by freight (typ. 1–2 weeks delivery in U.S.). $600 average shipping cost in the U.S. (plus tax if SC resident)	USA – Made by Huth Ben Pearson; ships via freight from dealer or manufacturer	USA – Made by Gray Machine & Welding; small size ships via parcel service	USA – American-made. ~600 lb; ships from WI warehouse via freight. Widely stocked in the U.S.	USA – Made in Florida (JD²) with all-steel construction. Ships as components (base ~70 lb, dies, etc.) via parcel service	Italy—Made by Ercolina (CML) in Italy. In the U.S., sold through Ercolina USA (Iowa) and dealers. ~600–800 lb; ships from U.S. distributor or import

The Versabend

First up, we have our patented tube bender for carports, the Versabend.

Category	Details
Motor	5 HP electric motor 1725 RPM; 220 V single-phase power supply (22 A) 3-phase power option available
Compatible Tube Sizes	2″, 2¼″, 2½″ square tubing 2″×3″ rectangular tubing (12–14 gauge)
Bender Type	Hydraulic with electric pump-driven cylinder
Price	$19,500 base price
Financing	Flexible financing plans available via our partner (American Capital)
Made In	Made in the USA, manufactured in South Carolina
Shipping	Ships as a 1,000lb crate Ships freight in 1–2 weeks U.S. shipping costs ~$600 Plus additional tax if SC resident

The Versabend runs on a powerful 5 HP electric motor with a speed of 1725 RPM, using a 220 V single-phase power supply (22 A). A 3-phase power option is also available for those who need it. This bender is compatible with 2″, 2¼″, and 2½″ square tubing, as well as 2″×3″ rectangular tubing in 12–14 gauge. Built as a hydraulic bender with an electric pump-driven cylinder, it delivers consistent strength and efficiency.

The base price is $19,500, with flexible financing plans available through our partner, American Capital. Every unit is proudly manufactured in South Carolina, USA. Shipping is handled in a 1,000 lb crate, typically sent via freight within 1–2 weeks. Average U.S. shipping costs are around $600, with additional tax applied for South Carolina residents.

Built specifically for carport framing, it allows you to complete bows of any size faster than before. The quick-change shims in its single die let you bend multiple tube sizes without buying or swapping extra dies, a huge advantage in high-throughput environments. This means you can bend four different tube sizes (2″, 2¼″, 2½″ square, and 2″×3″ rectangular) quickly and efficiently. Two employees bending for a traditional bent-style carport can process a bundle of 25 tubes in under 30 minutes—about a minute per bow.

Another advantage is its size-to-power ratio. With nearly 10 tons of bending force from a 5 HP motor, the Versabend hydraulic tube bender runs on a standard 220V single-phase hookup, eliminating the need for costly electrical upgrades. This makes it more accessible to small and mid-sized manufacturers compared to many other electric square tubing bender options.

Made in the USA with a 1,000 lb steel frame, the Versabend is built to last. Many units have been in the field for over 20 years with minimal maintenance. While the upfront cost is higher than some competitors, financing options and long-term productivity gains make it a smart and immediately effective investment for anyone searching for the best tube bender for carports.

The Versabend includes a free 3-year warranty!

Huth 2650 / 2660

The Huth 2650 and 2660 are heavy-duty hydraulic tube bender models from Huth Ben Pearson International. While not originally designed as a dedicated tube bender for carports, these machines can bend carport tubing when paired with the right dies, making them a versatile choice for shops that also handle greenhouses, picnic tables, and other structural framing projects.

Category	Details
Motor	Hydraulic system with ~58,000 lbs. of bending force; 7.5 HP motor with knee control for hands-free operation
Bending Features	Automatic depth-of-bend selector for repeatability
Compatible Tube Sizes	Can bend square, rectangular, and round tubing (capacity varies by die); commonly used for carport frame tubing, picnic tables, and other structural projects
Bender Type	Hydraulic rotary draw with interchangeable tooling for different profiles
Price	Varies by configuration, tooling package, and dealer; quotes provided based on intended applications
Financing	Available through select dealers; options depend on location and distributor
Made In	USA (by Huth Ben Pearson)
Shipping	Ships via freight from manufacturer or authorized dealer; weight varies by setup and tooling package

The Huth 2650/2660 series is designed to handle rectangular and round tubing with interchangeable tooling, making it a versatile option for projects like carports, greenhouses, picnic tables, and other framing applications. Powered by a 7.5 HP motor, the hydraulic system produces roughly 58,000 pounds of bending force and includes knee control for hands-free operation. An automatic depth-of-bend selector helps maintain consistency for repeat production.

Pricing for the 2650 and 2660 depends on the configuration, tooling package, and distributor, with quotes usually tailored to the application. Financing options are offered through select dealers, and units ship via freight with weight varying by tooling package.

While the Huth 2650/2660 delivers reliable bending power, the need for frequent die changes can slow production when focusing on single-radius carport bows. In comparison, the Versabend square tube bender uses a streamlined one-die system that reduces setup time and keeps production moving efficiently.

E-Z Bend 90

The E-Z Bend 90 from Gray Machine & Welding is a compact, manual square tube bender alternative that’s designed for quick, small-radius bends. While not purpose-built for carport framing, it is sometimes used for light fabrication or repair work where portability and simplicity are priorities.

Category	Details
Motor	Manual/lever-operated — no motor or hydraulics required
Bending Features	Basic 90° bending; limited to smaller tubing applications
Compatible Tube Sizes	Includes a small die set for round or light-duty tubing; not designed for large-radius bends typical of carport arches
Bender Type	Manual 90° tubing bender
Price	Varies by dealer; generally a lower-cost unit compared to hydraulic or electric benders
Financing	Not commonly offered; may be available through certain dealers or suppliers
Made In	USA (by Gray Machine & Welding)
Shipping	Ships via parcel service due to compact size and lighter weight

The E-Z Bend 90 is a traditional 90-degree bend option, designed to handle standard directional changes in duct runs. It provides a simple, fixed bend solution that fits typical setups where airflow redirection is needed. While it does its job in guiding airflow, the fixed 90-degree design means there is less flexibility compared to more advanced alternatives.

The E-Z Bend 90’s main advantage is its portability and low cost. However, it’s not suitable for large-radius bow production, making it better suited for small shops handling tight bends, field repairs, or light fabrication jobs rather than full-scale tube bender for carports production.

Baileigh RDB-150

The Baileigh RDB-150 from Baileigh Industries is a versatile hydraulic tube bender designed for tighter bends and gradual curves. While it’s capable of bending square tubing, it’s more often used for handrails, roll cages, or pipe furniture rather than high-volume carport bow production.

Category	Details
Motor	~2 HP hydraulic pump, requires 110 V single-phase power (standard wall outlet)
Compatible Tube Sizes	Up to 2½″ round tube (~⅛″ or .120″ wall); 2″ Sch. 40 pipe in one 180° stroke with 8″ CLR max bend radius
Bender Type	Hydraulic using a twin-cylinder rotary draw
Price	~ $7,500 base price; tooling and dies sold separately
Financing	Available through an in-house financing program
Made In	Made in the USA
Shipping	Weighs ~600 lbs; ships freight; units, spare dies, and parts widely stocked throughout the US

The Baileigh RDB-150 is a hydraulic rotary draw bender that runs on a 2 HP pump and plugs into a standard 110V outlet. It’s capable of bending up to 2½″ round tubing with walls around ⅛″ thick and can take 2″ Schedule 40 pipe through a full 180° stroke on an 8″ centerline radius. While its build is sturdy and made in the USA, the unit comes in at roughly 600 pounds, requires freight shipping, and starts at around $7,500 before adding the necessary tooling and dies. Financing is available, but because the dies are sold separately, the cost can climb quickly for shops that need multiple sizes.

When compared to the VersaBend, the difference becomes clear. The Baileigh is reliable within its limits, but the VersaBend offers broader bending capabilities, easier operation, and greater value without the add-on costs that drive up the price of machines like the RDB-150.

The Baileigh RDB-150 can be a reliable square tube bender for small shops with limited space, but for large-radius carport bows, it requires multiple dies and extra setup time compared to a dedicated tube bender for carports like the Versabend.

JD² Model 32

The JD2 Model 32 (with Hydraulic Assist) from JD2 Incorporated is known for its modular design and affordability, making it a popular entry-level square tube bender choice. It’s ideal for smaller shops that want to start basic and expand capabilities over time.

Category	Details
Motor	No built-in motor; operates manually or with a hydraulic drive add-on
Pump	Typically paired with external 1.5 HP air-hydraulic pump (110 V)
Compatible Tubes	Up to 2″ square tubing (mild steel; ~0.120″ wall) with base model; hydraulic assist required for larger sizes (over 1½″ square) and for round tube up to 2½″ OD (.120″ wall)
Bender Type	Hydraulic (manual or power ram)
Price	~$2,000–$5,000 with setup and extras; base frame $475 + hydraulic kit $945; pumps and dies sold separately
Financing	No direct financing; purchase via third-party financing, business loan, or credit card
Made In	USA (manufactured in Florida)
Shipping	Components ship separately by parcel; base weighs ~70 lbs; shipping cost varies

The JD2 Model 32 is one of the most recognized manual tube benders in the industry. Known for its strength and reliability, it’s been a go-to choice for fabricators who want consistent bends without complicated setup. With solid construction and straightforward operation, it handles a wide range of bending projects effectively, making it a trusted tool in many shops.

That said, for those looking for even more flexibility and efficiency, newer solutions like the Versabend offer smoother operation and a modern edge. While the Model 32 has built a strong reputation, Versabend takes bending to the next level, combining durability with ease of use for today’s needs.

While the JD2 Model 32 offers a flexible upgrade path, it’s not a turn-key tube bender for carports. It takes more research, component sourcing, and setup compared to the ready-to-run Versabend hydraulic tube bender.

Ercolina TB (Top Bender) 60

The Ercolina TB60 from CML International is a premium electric square tubing bender built for precision and automation. It’s well-suited for complex bends, tight-radius work, and high-end manufacturing environments.

Category	Details
Motor	Servo-electric drive (no hydraulics)
Power Requirements	3-phase power required – 480V standard; 220V 3-phase optional
Compatible Tube Sizes	Up to 2″ square tube (mild steel) using rotary draw; up to 2½″ round tube or 2″ Sch. 40 pipe
Bending Type	Fully-electric CNC rotary draw
Pricing	Entry-level: ~$10,300 (capacity: 2” tube); Advanced models: $22,000–$25,000
Financing	Available through Ercolina USA and distributors (leasing/financing options)
Made In	Italy
Shipping	Ships from Italy through U.S. dealers; weight: 600–800 lbs (depending on setup)

The Ercolina TB60 is a versatile rotary draw tube bender known for its solid performance across a wide range of bending jobs. It delivers consistent, high-quality bends for shops that need reliable precision, making it a trusted option for many fabricators working with medium-sized projects. The machine’s straightforward controls and sturdy build make it easy to use and dependable, whether handling standard tubing or more complex bending requirements.

That said, while the TB60 gets the job done, those looking for a more advanced edge often turn toward systems that prioritize efficiency, flexibility, and ease of use. That’s where machines like the Versabend quietly stand apart. With smoother operation, faster setup, and broader adaptability, the Versabend offers fabricators a more seamless experience without sacrificing the quality bends they expect.

The Ercolina TB60 is an advanced electric square tubing bender for shops needing CNC precision, but it’s overkill for most carport manufacturers. For high-volume, large-radius carport bows, a dedicated square tube bender for carports like the Versabend will be more efficient and cost-effective.

So, Which Square Tube Bender Is Best?

Each tube bender brings distinct advantages depending on your production needs, space, and budget. When looking at a square tube bender comparison, it’s important to evaluate your current workflow, facility capacity, bend complexity, and production goals not just for today or tomorrow, but with future growth in mind.

If your main focus is carport production, the choice narrows to a few contenders. Versabend is purpose-built for large-radius bows, bending four different tube sizes with a single die and no tooling changes, ideal for high-throughput carport manufacturing. Huth 2650/2660 benders are also capable of bending carport tubing with the right dies and are excellent all-around shop machines, but they require more setup time when switching sizes. E-Z Bend 90, on the other hand, is a compact, manual unit suited for tight bends and light fabrication work. It’s not designed for the large-radius carport arches most manufacturers need.

Outside the carport-specific segment, if you’re ready for high-end and fully automated manufacturing, then the Ercolina TB60 is best. However, if you are starting small and want a machine that will be able to grow with you, then the JD2 Model 32 is a great place to start, just make sure to do your research beforehand. For those working in a tight workshop and who don’t need too much bending power, the Baileigh RDB-150 does a solid job, but be sure you understand the tooling and die requirements before buying to save money.

But if you want a bending machine with serious power, without needing special electrical infrastructure, and requiring little maintenance, with a proven track record of over 20 years, then the Versabend is the perfect choice for you.

At Cold Spring Enterprises, we designed the Versabend to meet real production demands and deliver long-term value through simplicity, speed, and durability. It’s a turn-key bender that’s simple to operate, fast, consistent, and built to handle multiple tube sizes. Versabend units have been in use for over two decades and continue to prove their reliability in demanding production environments. Its reliability and ease of use help reduce downtime, so you spend less time troubleshooting and more time bending. A machine that runs smoothly is one you don’t have to think about, which means more uptime, less stress, and more time to focus on growing your business.

Have further questions or ready to get started? Read more about our Versabend tube bender, contact us online, or request a quote today!